Friday, July 4, 2014

Reading #s 19, 20 The Deaf World

7/4/14

Living in the Deaf World is reality for many people. I had some brief exposure to that world in two different schools during my career. The first was with two boys who were in my first grade class, in different years. They both were profoundly deaf. The parents were not however, but extremely supportive of what the school was doing at the time. Teachers, including myself, were trained in American Sign Language and how to adapt unit plans to include as much sign as possible.

The second encounter was also at a school, with an autistic, profoundly deaf girl just beginning puberty. All  that we could do for this girl was to teach her basic life skills, knowing that someday as an adult she would be living under supervision somewhere. One of her mothers was profoundly deaf, and the other was hard of hearing and used hearing aids. This family lived in the Deaf World.

I can understand how the two mothers felt in reading number 19, by Liza Mundy. Here, both moms were profoundly deaf, so they wanted their second baby to also be the same. The first child was also profoundly deaf. For this family being deaf is not a disability, but an ethnic group, as discussed by Harlan Lane in reading number 20.

Lane suggests that the Deaf World is an ethnic group because it has a name, community, behaviors, values, knowledge, kinship, customs, social structure, Language, Art, and History. He says that the aforementioned qualities signify an ethnic group. This makes sense to me. The only time I ever feel disabled by my diabetes is when my blood sugar level gets too low. Disability and ethnicity are social constructs, as are some other master statuses. You are born into a race and usually have a distinctive gender. There are some incidents when a baby is born with both physically visible genitalia. That is a different topic for another discussion.

In 2003 a law was passed to help with discrimination against minorities. This law will protect the Deaf World from discrimination for two reasons. One, the people are considered an Ethnic group. Two, they are considered a Linguistic minority. On page 181, Lane describes the  United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Persons Belonging to National, or Ethnic, Religious, and Linguistic Minorities.


1 comment:

  1. Hi Anne,
    You say you only feel disabled when your sugar is low... and some people who are deaf don't feel disabled when they are in the Deaf World. Another case where it's not a dichotomy, but a continuum...

    I taught my daughter basic signs when she was 6 months old, just for fun. I don't know if that is why she was a late talker, but she is still fascinated with ASL and has taken a few courses at college. I went with her to a lunch with her classmates and teachers, and I felt like such a foreigner... they were very patient, but my comprehension was limited and my daughter had to interpret for me.

    thanks, Claudia

    ReplyDelete