Thursday, July 17, 2014

Course Reflection

7/17/14

What are the aims of diversity? The aims are many and varied. Are they to create a utopia that does not exist? Are they to create a society where there is no discrimination, hatred, or fear of difference? Hopefully the aims of diversity are to help create a more peaceful world.

Since I am not a historian I learned some things about our country's past that are disturbing. The worst thing I learned about is the one-drop rule. We discussed it in class and I read about it in article #2, Who is Black? One Nation's Definition, by E. James Davis. The author explains it to mean that a black person is someone who has any known African black ancestry.

Article #3, The Evolution of Identity shows a chart of the changes in categories on the U. S. Census. In 1890 the census had categories called quadroon and octoroon. How demoralizing these names sound. The first category is someone who is one-quarter black and the second one is a person who is one-eighth black. We now refer to such people as African American. A law called Directive Number 15 changed all that. There are now six categories and a person is allowed to choose more than one racial category to define their identity.

When my daughters were very young we were traveling by car to New York City. At one of the highway rest stops we were in McDonald's and there were some African Americans. My girls had never seen dark skinned people before coming from northern Vermont. My older girl asked me why their skin was brown. I responded that people have skin of different colors. The African American woman walking past our table stopped and asked my daughter if she wanted to feel her skin and held out her arm. My daughter touched the woman's arm and said, "It feels just like mine." She was probably around two or three when this occurred. I raised my girls to be non-racist just as my parents did with me.

As a Reading Recovery teacher I have read many of Marie M. Clay's works. In one book, By Different Paths to Common Outcomes, (1998), chapter 16 is about accommodating diversity in early literacy learning. On page 223 Clay says, "Diversity refers to any and all the variants of individual difference and is not limited to cultural, ethnic, or linguistic diversity." To me this sounds like everything I learned in class. On page 228 Clay also refers to diversity in this statement, "Today we are better than we used to be at accepting cultural difference, language difference, and gender difference, but because we frequently do not acknowledge diversity in ways of learning we have been open to blunders in this area." My personal philosophy is and always has been, to treat each child as an individual and to teach them accordingly. This idea has been reinforced by Marie Clay and Reading Recovery. It is my hope that all teachers think the same way as I do.

I am also a member of the National Education Association, (NEA) and receive their magazines periodically.
In those there is usually a diversity calendar according to months of the year. It gives information such as April is National Autism Month. It also tells specific dates of each month and events that are happening in each particular year. You can find this calendar online without being a member. Just google, NEA diversity calendar.

Learning about the master statuses was interesting. I never thought about how much these categories affected people's lives. There are the obvious ones such as race, gender, social class, and disability. Age is also a master status but not discussed in the book, The Meaning of Difference: American Constructions of Race, Sex and Gender, Social Class, Sexual Orientation, and Disability, by Rosenblum and Travis, (2011). Sexual orientation never seemed that important to me except for that's how some people are. I now know that it is important for societal reasons.

In conclusion, I think that everything related to human beings and who they are, affect how they are looked at in society. My goal is to help educate people of all ages learn that being different is a good thing. We should all appreciate our individual differences. So, to me the aims of diversity are to realize that everybody is different and we should always remember that it doesn't matter what another person is. Just enjoy them.



 

 









Monday, July 14, 2014

Reading #s 23, 36 Ethnicity

7/14/14

These two articles are about ethnic identities.

In article #23, by Jelita McLeod, she talks about how she is quite often mistaken for something other than what she is, which is half white and half Asian. McLeod opens up with a story about an elevator ride with an African American man. He asked her what her race was and when she told him he responded with disappointment and said, "Oh, I thought you were one of us" (p. 242). People need to feel connected to others in one way or another. In this case the man in the elevator was hoping for someone to communicate with from his own minority race. McLeod has also been mistaken for Hispanic, Native American and Arab. She has heard these mistakes all her life. The author closes her article by saying, "I know who I am. It's everyone else that's having trouble."

This makes me feel bad that I sometimes can not tell what a person's race may be. It doesn't really matter to me what a person's background is, but I don't want to offend others by having to ask. So I don't ask, or at least I try to be tactful about asking. Usually I ask where a person's accent is from. I don't know if that's any better than just asking what race, or nationality they are. Caring about skin color is not something important to me. I want to know the person for who they are personally, not racially.

Blink in Black and White, by Malcolm Gladwell, (article #36), is about a test I had never heard of; the Implicit Association Test, or IAT. People make connections to many things in life. This test shows the connections, both conscious and unconscious, that we humans have attitudes about, specifically about race, gender and height. It shows that we make connections more easily and quickly to pairs of things that we are familiar with. For unfamiliar pairings, the connections come more slowly.

This test can be a predictor of how people will behave in certain situations, and with certain people. It is about being either African American or white and how our unconscious brain thinks about the opposite race. It also shows what we were raised to believe. On p. 354, the author writes that it may show that our unconscious attitudes do not agree with our conscious stated beliefs. This is kind of scary to me because what I think about race may not be what my unconscious thoughts really are. I hope my feelings towards different types of people come out showing what I really do think. I hope my conscious self and my unconscious self do agree with each other. I like to think that they do.

Sunday, July 13, 2014

Reading #10 Sex Verification

7/13/14

The author, Alice Dreger, discusses the case of a woman who is being questioned as to whether she is in fact a woman because of her athletic prowess. The article also explains how biology works in determining gender. Well, it's not as easy as we always thought. Science has discovered that there are multiple varieties of males and females as far as hormones and genitals go. A person can look male on the outside but have internal organs that are female, and vice versa. This is how Mother Nature works. I always say, "Don't mess with Mother Nature." At least that's what I tell my husband when the weather doesn't cooperate in regards to our garden.

Dreger queries if it is fair that biology makes some women stronger or taller. She says it is fair, and I agree. I think it is fair because some women are more intelligent than others, or better at baking, or whatever. It's all related to how nature deals out our cards, so to speak.

Will doctors ever know how to truly label someone male or female? Is it okay for there to be such discrepancies as discussed in Dreger's article? I think it is okay. A saying I heard during my lifetime is, "Variety is the spice of life." Let's all just enjoy what and who we are.

Saturday, July 12, 2014

Reading #s 3, 52, 55

7/12/14

These three readings all have to do with identity.

The Evolution of Identity by the Washington Post is a timeline from the U.S. Census. It starts in 1860 and goes until the 2000 census. Over time the census has changed the way people are categorized. The only constant race category is white. There were two categories that were only listed in the 1890 census; quadroon and octoroon. A quadroon was a person with at least one-quarter black heritage and an octoroon was a person with at least one-eighth black heritage. Both of these are above the one-sixteenth, or one-drop rule amount. I wonder why it changed during only one year, 1890?

Systems keep changing, they can't help it. According to Allan G. Johnson in article #52, "No social system lasts forever." Becoming part of a solution is very challenging for people, but "We affect one another all the time without knowing it" (p. 505). On page 504, Johnson writes that Gandhi once said, "Nothing we do as individuals matters, but it's vitally important to do it anyway." This must be how we as individuals can become part of a solution to change the history of discrimination for the better. If all the people in the world would just change their nasty thoughts of who is better than whom, we would have a more peaceful existence. I can only hope.

In reading #55, by Shuddhabrata Sengupta, I learned that societies are intersectional. The author believes that identities are negotiated minefields. I think this means that throughout history there were and still are, victims and aggressors. These roles sometimes switch with each other because they are always intersecting. Everyone believes that everything is all about them, at some point in their lives. I know I do. How about you?

Thursday, July 10, 2014

Reading #s 33, 34 Disability Denial

7/10/14

Both authors, John Hockenberry and Sally French wrote about personal experiences of denial. Hockenberry was denied cab service by most drivers who would look at him in his wheelchair and then drive on by. Some would sit in their seat while Hockenberry struggled to get in, and would not take care of the wheelchair for him. He would end up getting out to look for another taxi. He even had one violent incident with a cab driver that was appalling to read about. This awful story begins on page 311, if you want to read it.

There was one taxi driver that treated Hockenberry with respect, and picked him up twice. Unfortunately he turned out to be Mahmoud Abu Holima, one of the people to plant bombs in the World Trade Center, February 26, 1993. I'm not sure of the significance of this fact, but I think it tells me that all terrorists are not discriminatory towards disabled people. Maybe even helpful. I like to believe there is positive in everyone, even among the negative.

Sally French's experience is different than John Hockenberry's. She was the one denying her disability. Not the cab drivers. She was born with limited sight, some would call legally blind. She could not see colors when young and has trouble seeing anything when the sun is too bright. Since she always heard people pleading with her, "Don't you see the rainbow?" she would just say yes to appease her family. French did not do herself a favor by this denial of her true self. It is not good to hide such things from the world. If someone has a hidden medical disability but doesn't share that fact with others it could become harmful to that person.

It is also not wise to deny one's self the pleasure of experiencing life to the fullest. I enjoy life and hope that most other people do, however they like to.


Tuesday, July 8, 2014

Reading #s 31, 44, 45, 46

7/8/14

Inequality, how unfair!

I still don't get why people all over the world can agree or take part in racial discrimination. After reading the above four articles, I am even more disgusted in the behavior of so many of our country's citizens. 

As I read about social inequality in article #31, Alejandro Reuss wrote that such inequality was related to the early death of people. Social inequality is also more prevalent with minorities. These groups generally live in poverty. The mortality rate was higher in people living in poverty because they had a lack of access to appropriate health care. Usually because of no health insurance. I am glad that our state of Vermont has good insurance for those living in poverty. Hopefully with the Affordable Care Act others with no way to get insurance will be able to now. Although some people have zero income and can't even pay for the minimum required by Federal law. That's another conversation. 

On page 443, in article #44, the author discusses crossing the color line. I learned more about the one-drop rule and how it was dealt with in Virginia. In 1691 a statute was enacted that interracial marriage was illegal. If a mixed race couple was caught they would be banished for life from even entering Virginia. If a person had one-sixteenth or more of "black blood" they were considered negro. As you may be able to tell I have trouble even writing some of this. 

Framing Class by Diana Kendall was about how the media constructs reality, mostly on television, but also magazines, papers, movies and more. The working class, and poor, are more likely to watch TV. They like to emulate the middle and upper classes since they cannot be in those categories. Kendall calls this, Emulation Framing. This is an ideological construction that the media frames for those in poverty. The media sees poverty as a problem of individuals, not society, (p. 451).  

Lastly, article #46 is also about inequality. Cheryl I. Harris, and Devon W. Carbado, discuss how this was evident after Katrina hit New Orleans. This was clearly racial inequality between, blacks and whites. The black people were assumed to be criminals looting stores. The white people were assumed to be homeless from the hurricane, and finding food to survive. This is because mainstream America does not see racism as a problem. They are "color blind." Racial frames shape our perceptions of the facts. People are ready to accept the journalists perceptions. Again, the media is constructing how we see things.  

Friday, July 4, 2014

Reading #s 19, 20 The Deaf World

7/4/14

Living in the Deaf World is reality for many people. I had some brief exposure to that world in two different schools during my career. The first was with two boys who were in my first grade class, in different years. They both were profoundly deaf. The parents were not however, but extremely supportive of what the school was doing at the time. Teachers, including myself, were trained in American Sign Language and how to adapt unit plans to include as much sign as possible.

The second encounter was also at a school, with an autistic, profoundly deaf girl just beginning puberty. All  that we could do for this girl was to teach her basic life skills, knowing that someday as an adult she would be living under supervision somewhere. One of her mothers was profoundly deaf, and the other was hard of hearing and used hearing aids. This family lived in the Deaf World.

I can understand how the two mothers felt in reading number 19, by Liza Mundy. Here, both moms were profoundly deaf, so they wanted their second baby to also be the same. The first child was also profoundly deaf. For this family being deaf is not a disability, but an ethnic group, as discussed by Harlan Lane in reading number 20.

Lane suggests that the Deaf World is an ethnic group because it has a name, community, behaviors, values, knowledge, kinship, customs, social structure, Language, Art, and History. He says that the aforementioned qualities signify an ethnic group. This makes sense to me. The only time I ever feel disabled by my diabetes is when my blood sugar level gets too low. Disability and ethnicity are social constructs, as are some other master statuses. You are born into a race and usually have a distinctive gender. There are some incidents when a baby is born with both physically visible genitalia. That is a different topic for another discussion.

In 2003 a law was passed to help with discrimination against minorities. This law will protect the Deaf World from discrimination for two reasons. One, the people are considered an Ethnic group. Two, they are considered a Linguistic minority. On page 181, Lane describes the  United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Persons Belonging to National, or Ethnic, Religious, and Linguistic Minorities.


Thursday, July 3, 2014

Reading #s 6, 7

7/3/14

More articles about race. In this case they are about being white, and/or multiracial.

On p. 89, Ruth Frankenburg writes that whiteness is taken for granted sometimes, because being white has advantages and privileges that other races in America do not have as abundantly. She talks about two kinds of whiteness: truly/only white and, white plus some other race. We used to call this biracial, but in the next reading I learned about multiracial people.

In article #7 Jennifer Lee and Frank D. Bean discuss the idea that America used to be a biracial nation, mostly whites and some blacks. Now we live in a multiracial nation with multiple ethnic groups within each race. In fact, 1:40 persons in America is multiracial. To me this sounds like our country is finally becoming a little more tolerant about intermarriages. As of the 2000 census people could choose one or more races on the form.

All of this thinking about race, gives me hope that someday people all across the globe will become tolerant of each other. I grew up in the 60s and 70s: Give Peace a Chance. Okay, so we had to fight for our freedom, time and time again throughout history. However, I am glad the United States is a peaceful country at home, but what about in all the other countries we are supposedly helping?


Monday, June 30, 2014

Reading #s 1, 2, 47, 54

6/30/14

More Thoughts About Racism

I want to start out by apologizing to David. I sometimes speak out loud when I shouldn't. Joking about his age was thoughtless, even though I am older and a member of AARP. I've actually used this membership to get discounts at hotels and restaurants. Anyway, I am sorry David to have made a joke at your expense. Does that make me racist? Growing up I never liked racial jokes or laughed at them and I still don't. 

After reading the above mentioned readings about racism, I felt awful. How could people behave in the ways I read about? On p. 49, Audrey Smedley mentions that skin color differences did not mean anything in the ancient world or during the Middle Ages. She says that in the 16th century the word race was used only as a classification. During the 18th century race and inequality evolved in the American colonies as a form of social identification. Smedley also says that race is a social invention. So is this a construction of human ridiculousness? 

I read more about the one-drop rule in E. James Davis's article. This only made me more disgusted about our country's history. Why did people in America think this way? Why do they still? Other countries do not believe in this rule. All of this thinking makes me not be proud to be an American. I know Independence Day is soon to be upon us, but do I really want to celebrate our country's freedom at the cost of others who were persecuted and kept as slaves? 

In reading #54, Paul Kivel talks about multi-cultural relationships. He says that at first people are friendly and polite. They may feel pleased with themselves for having friends of a different race. Later, the relationships may turn to not so friendly when one person gets angry with the other person in such relationships. Again, absolutely stupid! I have a brother-in-law married to a wonderful woman who is African American and they adopted a baby who is bi-racial. They have a happy life.

I also read the article by Randall Kennedy, The Protean N-Word. Yet another reading about racism and how bad it is. On p. 464, the author talks about how in the 1800s and 1900s the word "nigger" was used regularly in literature, political debates, cartoons, and songs. I just had a hard time typing that N-word, that's how much I hate it. On p. 466, Kennedy tells how Prosecutor Christopher Darden called it the "filthiest, dirtiest, nastiest word in the English language."

On p. 471 I read something that I had already heard about sometime during my life. It was about when blacks use nigger among themselves, it is actually okay. This is the opposite of when they use Negro to mean a black person  who wants to blend in with white people. Are these people being racist against whites? Another ridiculous thing.


Monday, June 23, 2014

Reading #s 48, 49, 50, 53

6/23/14

These four articles are somewhat related. They all discuss discrimination yet each one addresses a different  category, specifically, gender, race, disability, and social class.  

In article #50 it talks about Rosa Parks standing up for herself by sitting up front on the bus in 1955. That led to other minority groups such as those living in wheelchairs, stand up for their rights as well. In turn other disabilities were added to the list of those living with certain types of limitations. Finally, in 1990 the Americans with Disabilities Act came. People with disabilities make up the largest minority group in our country, (#48).

I am a person with two autoimmune diseases that are covered by this act, under section 504. Section 504 covers many medical issues that may interfere with a person's learning, but they do not qualify for an IEP. For me if I am having trouble staying focused, I know that is a signal to me that I probably need to check my sugar and act accordingly. The ADA has helped both my daughter and myself to be able to deal with issues. I appreciate it.

Article #49 talks about discrimination of women in regard to wages. For as long as I remember women were paid less than men in certain types of jobs, doing the same work. When Lilly Ledbetter learned about the wage discrepancy she took the company she worked for to court. She initially lost her case of discrimination but later on won a different yet related victory, when President Obama signed into law the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay act in 2009.

My last article is about social class and a person who is generous with his money to help particular grassroots causes. This is in article #53. Although he told us that he doesn't donate to larger causes such as diabetes research, I'm still in agreement with him that other wealthy individuals and families should also be free with their money, to some extent. Wimsatt does it because he cares about our planet and wants others to help out too. He also thinks that people should care like he does in the way they are able, no matter what social class they are in.










Sunday, June 22, 2014

Reading #s 37, 38, 42

6/22/14

These three readings have one main underlying theme; segregation by race and skin color. One week before his death in 1968, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. said: 
     "The grave problem facing us is the problem of economic deprivation, with the syndrome of bad housing        poor education, and improper health facilities all surrounding us." (p. 418)

He was right in his thinking, in my opinion. Unfortunately, this problem is still happening today. There are still neighborhoods of ghettos, and people living in poverty. It is even happening here in Vermont. Poverty is rampant in Franklin county where I teach. There are not many African Americans living here so the discrimination found is due to the living conditions that some families can only afford. Living in poverty because of other circumstances one has to deal with is very difficult, especially for children. Sometimes the only meals such children may have in one day are breakfast and lunch, which are eaten at school. So the idea of economic deprivation does affect us all in one way or another. 

Housing opportunities are mostly determined by race and ethnicity. This also happens in our state but is mostly seen in the cities here. Our cities are not very large but there are definite signs of discrimination and segregation in them. Segregation is obvious because race and ethnicity are quite visible to humans. Even six month old babies are seeing the differences. When shown pictures of people's faces of different races and colors, babies will stare longer at the unknown, and different pictures. They recognize the race of what their parents are. I wonder if a mixed race set of parents would bring different results for the babies to stare at longer? Would they recognize both races more than the other unknown races? 

  

Sunday, June 15, 2014

Readings 12, 13, 14

6/15/14

All three of these readings have a similar theme; social equality or inequality, whether it be about income, wealth, or class. These things are not readily visible like race or gender. People can sort of know by the way we dress, cars we drive or even health status and education level, but it is not the first thing we see upon meeting new people.

We in America do not live in an egalitarian society where all people are equal. We live in a society where class, wealth or income dictates what social groups we are a part of. People are born into the level of where their parents are, and are raised accordingly. On page 136, the 20th century philosopher John Rawls is mentioned as having said that people are happily born without knowing what position in society they are going to be. He calls it a fair society.

I mentioned in our game last Tuesday that I was born into a family of doctors, lawyers and jewelers. This is true but none of them were extremely wealthy, or in the upper class of society. If they were then that is before my time. I do consider myself and my ancestors to be in the professional middle class. We are/were well educated, have reasonably good health and fairly good incomes.

Because my birth mother died from cancer when I was six, I did get a small inheritance after my grandmother, her mother, died in 1985. I hope to pass that on to my children someday, when I don't need it anymore. I believe in what is called reverse inheritance where my children will take care of me like I did them. I actually tell them that on occasion. My younger daughter, the nurse, tells me that I am going in a nursing home. We joke about it back and forth.

Currently, I am helping my older daughter secure loans for pharmacy school because this is the way my family is. My father helped me and my two young children after my divorce when we were in situational poverty. I already had my teaching degree but just didn't have a job for awhile. Once that changed I was on my own again, and then met my current husband and life is grand, as they say.

I read about something called the Gini coefficient that tells about the level of inequality in nations. In America the gap is increasing too rapidly. The rich are definitely getting richer and the poor are getting poorer, so the middle class is still in the middle but there are less people there. Many people in the middle are either climbing the ladder to success, or falling behind. It's a sad situation. However, I did read that most people stay at a similar level of wealth, or class as from whence their ancestors came.





Thursday, June 12, 2014

Reading #s 9 & 24

6/12/14

Both of these readings discuss the hierarchy of gender in the United States and other countries. Being male has always been regarded as the dominant gender. Of course we were raised to believe this because of men's political power and brute strength. Women were meant to be the nurturers because we give birth, stayed home, cooked, cleaned, and raised the children.

Well I believe this is not necessarily true in these modern times. Also because I am an independent, free-thinking woman. Okay, so I do agree with the brute strength idea, being a small woman, but there are many women who are much stronger physically than men. For instance, one of my daughter's friends is a petite woman who is a body builder. She is also an operating room nurse and can lift obese people onto the gurneys, with others helping of course. My daughter is also an operating room nurse, also petite but not a body builder, who can also help lift such people onto gurneys.

I, however, have given birth twice and think that makes me stronger than any man in a different sense. Not because men cannot give birth but because I don't think that men can handle it emotionally. My husband is sometimes more emotional than I am. He is physically stronger than me though. Go figure. He is a poor, starving musician and I am the breadwinner right now. Talk about role reversals. He has actually called himself a househusband.  

In historic times men were dominant because of their physical strength and they provided for their families, but they also beat and raped their women into submission to prove their dominance. This was an awful way to live and I am glad to have not been alive then. I abhor violence. Unfortunately, the beatings and rapes do still happen but when men, or women, are caught and tried for these things, they go to jail most of the time.

So here I am once again waffling between two sides of the coin, so to speak. Being a Libra I always have to weigh both sides of everything. Making choices is not always an easy task for me.

Monday, June 9, 2014

Reading #35

6/9/14

While reading about people who are legally blind I felt outraged at how they are treated sometimes. Being forced or convinced to choose if they are sighted or blind is insensitive. Some people are downright rude to the legally blind and don't consider them blind at all if the person is not carrying a white stick or have a guide dog. It makes me think about how the insensitive people were raised. What were they taught at home? They certainly couldn't have learned it from me or any of my friends who also teach elementary school. They may have overheard some teachers speaking rudely about disabled kids in the hallway, (which they should not do), or at a store. Who knows?

I learned a new word from this article, "dubiety", which I had to look up. It simply means someone is doubtful about something. I read it on page 324, paragraph 3, sentence 2, "In an effort to relieve their own dubiety, sighted people try to force borderland blind people to choose one side or the other ..."

Having a different disability myself, I can almost empathize with borderland blind people in the fact that my diabetes is not readily visible to others. I do have a bright orange tag that lets me park in handicapped spots. My doctor approved this because there have been times when I had extremely low blood sugar and needed assistance. Also because I just feel out of sorts and need a quick place to park and test my levels.

I have been treated rudely by strangers when I use my tag, and someone once put a nasty note on my car while I was inside a grocery store. Who were they to judge my reasons for parking where I am legally allowed to? I actually told this to a clerk at the DMV once when I lost my tag and needed a new one, people say nasty things to me because I don't look disabled. She told me not to be ashamed about where I park and those rude people have no right to question what I am doing.

In the article, Larry reported that he doesn't "give a shit what others think." Most of the time I don't care either, but sometimes the comments are hurtful, and it makes me feel sad that I have a disease that I did not ask for, or cause upon myself.

 

Sunday, June 8, 2014

Reading #30

6/8

This article was about social class, specifically the middle class, working class and the poor, and how it affects students' education. At my school we did a book study for all faculty and staff about living in poverty, so this article reminded me of that book, which I will have to find at school in order to reference it.

It is unfortunate that children experience education differently due to what particular class they and their families are considered to be part of. I understand about each of the three classes mentioned and have lived in each. I teach young students that also fit in one class or another. Personally, I believe that each child deserves an equal education whatever their life circumstances may be.

Public education of young children generally cones down to money! The more affluent towns have bigger school budgets and can afford to take care of each individual child's educational needs. Rural towns have a mix of all classes, but still don't have the budgets to "get the best" for their children.

Having taught in rural elementary schools for 18 years I see the types of students that are spoken of in this reading. I teach them every day. My advanced reading students usually come from middle class families, but not always. Many families are living in situational poverty because of lack of work, or some other unknown reason. Those that live in generational poverty are very different. This is how ancestry goes sometimes. The families are unsure of how to break away from the struggles.

After reading this paper my attitude is still just as strong as before the reading. Each child deserves the best education possible that is tailored just right for each individual.

Thursday, June 5, 2014

Essentialism v Constructionism


6/5/14

First, I hope my classmates and professor are able to view my posts. I am still learning how this works. Please let me know.

As for being either a constructionist or an essentialist, I would count myself somewhere in the middle of the two. Although probably more of an essentialist because that's how I was raised, to follow the path of what is essential to succeed in life. Also, to me this is the reality of the world that I did not create.

I would like to think more like a constructionist so I can help create and possibly change some of my school's core values and mission statements. These things were created by others before me. I agree with some statements but would like to change some too. For instance, we have some good values that state that we should be the best teachers we can be and treat all students equally. However, not all students will meet the expectations of the CCSS. We as a school can try our best to prepare students for the future and we can also hope for the best from our students. Due to outside circumstances not in the school's control I go back to being an essentialist in my thinking.

 Since the Common Core State Standards were created by business people and political leaders they have decided for teachers what skills are necessary to teach students for them to become productive members of society. As I stated in the last paragraph, not all students will meet those standards and expectations. There are many outside of school influences that make this true. It has to do with the diversity issues of race, religion, gender, disability, social status, and just plain old self-motivation.

Speaking of race, or ethnicity, I do not agree with the one-drop rule. I think it is inhumane how it began with slavery and the owners of slaves procreating  with their slaves so they can produce more slaves. Absolutely ridiculous. As a young child in the 60's I attended a Waldorf School from age three in nursery school to age 11 when I finished sixth grade. Everyone at that school treated each other respectively, there were no issues with the diverse population that attended.

When I went to a public junior high school it was different. I actually hated it because there was quite obvious racism happening. This was in the late 60's when you would hear stories about hangings of African Americans, then called blacks or coloreds. The KKK was still prominent and constantly in the news. It was talked about in school. My best friend at the time was an African American and I would defend her to those kids that were openly rude to her.

So, all in all, I still consider myself in between being an essentialist and a constructionist.


Monday, June 2, 2014

Human Rights article


6/2/14

As I was reading the article by Banks, (2009), I found it interesting to learn about the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, (UDHR), written in 1948. This is a global declaration of how all peoples should be treated equally and fairly. In this day and age it still is not happening, unfortunately. I was raised to believe that everyone from any race, religion, gender, disability, social class, and sexual orientation should be treated the same as I wanted to be treated.

On page 102 it said that in the late 1800's to the early 1900's immigrants were taught both hope and shame when coming to this country. To me this is contradictory. How can one have hope for a new life in a new land but upon arrival be treated shamefully? Well, my family moved from Long Island to Vermont in 1971 when I was in high school and we were looked down upon and called, "flatlanders". I felt shame and not accepted for who I was. Luckily, that is different now for me. Not many people know that I was not born here. My children were born here however and never were called stupid names like I was. They are in fact seventh generation Vermonters, on their father's side.

I agree with the author when he wrote on page 104, that being culturally assimilated is different than being structurally excluded. You can be accepted in a community but you may not be equal in terms of education, or have voting rights, or even hold political positions in some places.

A quote from King, (1963/1994) states, "A threat to justice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." I read this on page 109 and wholeheartedly agree.