Thursday, June 5, 2014
Essentialism v Constructionism
6/5/14
First, I hope my classmates and professor are able to view my posts. I am still learning how this works. Please let me know.
As for being either a constructionist or an essentialist, I would count myself somewhere in the middle of the two. Although probably more of an essentialist because that's how I was raised, to follow the path of what is essential to succeed in life. Also, to me this is the reality of the world that I did not create.
I would like to think more like a constructionist so I can help create and possibly change some of my school's core values and mission statements. These things were created by others before me. I agree with some statements but would like to change some too. For instance, we have some good values that state that we should be the best teachers we can be and treat all students equally. However, not all students will meet the expectations of the CCSS. We as a school can try our best to prepare students for the future and we can also hope for the best from our students. Due to outside circumstances not in the school's control I go back to being an essentialist in my thinking.
Since the Common Core State Standards were created by business people and political leaders they have decided for teachers what skills are necessary to teach students for them to become productive members of society. As I stated in the last paragraph, not all students will meet those standards and expectations. There are many outside of school influences that make this true. It has to do with the diversity issues of race, religion, gender, disability, social status, and just plain old self-motivation.
Speaking of race, or ethnicity, I do not agree with the one-drop rule. I think it is inhumane how it began with slavery and the owners of slaves procreating with their slaves so they can produce more slaves. Absolutely ridiculous. As a young child in the 60's I attended a Waldorf School from age three in nursery school to age 11 when I finished sixth grade. Everyone at that school treated each other respectively, there were no issues with the diverse population that attended.
When I went to a public junior high school it was different. I actually hated it because there was quite obvious racism happening. This was in the late 60's when you would hear stories about hangings of African Americans, then called blacks or coloreds. The KKK was still prominent and constantly in the news. It was talked about in school. My best friend at the time was an African American and I would defend her to those kids that were openly rude to her.
So, all in all, I still consider myself in between being an essentialist and a constructionist.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Anne:
ReplyDeleteAre you sure someone can be in the middle between an essentialist and a constructivist? What would that be like?
Wow, what a tumultuous time to live in! I'm proud to know someone who would stand-up for others even when there was so much controversy surrounding the subject at the time. I'm also with you regarding the common core standards. You would think that "standards" would be created in a way that would best represent the entire population as is, rather than what they would like our population to be.
ReplyDeleteAnne,
ReplyDeleteI agree that the one-drop rule is ridiculous, and even more so that it is still evident today. Even worse is that the African-American community seems to have accepted it, as evidenced by lower numbers marrying outside of the race. As is true of any group, differences between the groups are emphasized in order to better define the group itself.
You said: “Since the Common Core State Standards were created by business people and political leaders they have decided for teachers what skills are necessary to teach students for them to become productive members of society.” I agree that we are teaching students the skills necessary to become productive members of society, as they will add to our national wealth rather than drawing from it, as welfare recipients do. Who do you believe decided what those skills were before CCSS was created? Who do you think should determine those skills? Who ultimately gets to decide what education is for?
I think the stated goal of CCSS is admirable: by having the same high standards for everyone, then everyone will benefit. You mention that issues of diversity makes it harder for some to succeed. I agree that certain students will find it easier to be successful because of the advantages they have had from before birth. I think our job as teachers is to recognized the disadvantages of other students, but to use that as a starting point rather than a quitting point. Let’s help each student to be as successful as they can be. And remember that we always need cannon fodder and gas station attendants.
Essentially a constructivist? Construct the essentials? I think we all construct our own reality... what does that make me?