7/14/14
These two articles are about ethnic identities.
In article #23, by Jelita McLeod, she talks about how she is quite often mistaken for something other than what she is, which is half white and half Asian. McLeod opens up with a story about an elevator ride with an African American man. He asked her what her race was and when she told him he responded with disappointment and said, "Oh, I thought you were one of us" (p. 242). People need to feel connected to others in one way or another. In this case the man in the elevator was hoping for someone to communicate with from his own minority race. McLeod has also been mistaken for Hispanic, Native American and Arab. She has heard these mistakes all her life. The author closes her article by saying, "I know who I am. It's everyone else that's having trouble."
This makes me feel bad that I sometimes can not tell what a person's race may be. It doesn't really matter to me what a person's background is, but I don't want to offend others by having to ask. So I don't ask, or at least I try to be tactful about asking. Usually I ask where a person's accent is from. I don't know if that's any better than just asking what race, or nationality they are. Caring about skin color is not something important to me. I want to know the person for who they are personally, not racially.
Blink in Black and White, by Malcolm Gladwell, (article #36), is about a test I had never heard of; the Implicit Association Test, or IAT. People make connections to many things in life. This test shows the connections, both conscious and unconscious, that we humans have attitudes about, specifically about race, gender and height. It shows that we make connections more easily and quickly to pairs of things that we are familiar with. For unfamiliar pairings, the connections come more slowly.
This test can be a predictor of how people will behave in certain situations, and with certain people. It is about being either African American or white and how our unconscious brain thinks about the opposite race. It also shows what we were raised to believe. On p. 354, the author writes that it may show that our unconscious attitudes do not agree with our conscious stated beliefs. This is kind of scary to me because what I think about race may not be what my unconscious thoughts really are. I hope my feelings towards different types of people come out showing what I really do think. I hope my conscious self and my unconscious self do agree with each other. I like to think that they do.
Monday, July 14, 2014
Sunday, July 13, 2014
Reading #10 Sex Verification
7/13/14
The author, Alice Dreger, discusses the case of a woman who is being questioned as to whether she is in fact a woman because of her athletic prowess. The article also explains how biology works in determining gender. Well, it's not as easy as we always thought. Science has discovered that there are multiple varieties of males and females as far as hormones and genitals go. A person can look male on the outside but have internal organs that are female, and vice versa. This is how Mother Nature works. I always say, "Don't mess with Mother Nature." At least that's what I tell my husband when the weather doesn't cooperate in regards to our garden.
Dreger queries if it is fair that biology makes some women stronger or taller. She says it is fair, and I agree. I think it is fair because some women are more intelligent than others, or better at baking, or whatever. It's all related to how nature deals out our cards, so to speak.
Will doctors ever know how to truly label someone male or female? Is it okay for there to be such discrepancies as discussed in Dreger's article? I think it is okay. A saying I heard during my lifetime is, "Variety is the spice of life." Let's all just enjoy what and who we are.
The author, Alice Dreger, discusses the case of a woman who is being questioned as to whether she is in fact a woman because of her athletic prowess. The article also explains how biology works in determining gender. Well, it's not as easy as we always thought. Science has discovered that there are multiple varieties of males and females as far as hormones and genitals go. A person can look male on the outside but have internal organs that are female, and vice versa. This is how Mother Nature works. I always say, "Don't mess with Mother Nature." At least that's what I tell my husband when the weather doesn't cooperate in regards to our garden.
Dreger queries if it is fair that biology makes some women stronger or taller. She says it is fair, and I agree. I think it is fair because some women are more intelligent than others, or better at baking, or whatever. It's all related to how nature deals out our cards, so to speak.
Will doctors ever know how to truly label someone male or female? Is it okay for there to be such discrepancies as discussed in Dreger's article? I think it is okay. A saying I heard during my lifetime is, "Variety is the spice of life." Let's all just enjoy what and who we are.
Saturday, July 12, 2014
Reading #s 3, 52, 55
7/12/14
These three readings all have to do with identity.
The Evolution of Identity by the Washington Post is a timeline from the U.S. Census. It starts in 1860 and goes until the 2000 census. Over time the census has changed the way people are categorized. The only constant race category is white. There were two categories that were only listed in the 1890 census; quadroon and octoroon. A quadroon was a person with at least one-quarter black heritage and an octoroon was a person with at least one-eighth black heritage. Both of these are above the one-sixteenth, or one-drop rule amount. I wonder why it changed during only one year, 1890?
Systems keep changing, they can't help it. According to Allan G. Johnson in article #52, "No social system lasts forever." Becoming part of a solution is very challenging for people, but "We affect one another all the time without knowing it" (p. 505). On page 504, Johnson writes that Gandhi once said, "Nothing we do as individuals matters, but it's vitally important to do it anyway." This must be how we as individuals can become part of a solution to change the history of discrimination for the better. If all the people in the world would just change their nasty thoughts of who is better than whom, we would have a more peaceful existence. I can only hope.
In reading #55, by Shuddhabrata Sengupta, I learned that societies are intersectional. The author believes that identities are negotiated minefields. I think this means that throughout history there were and still are, victims and aggressors. These roles sometimes switch with each other because they are always intersecting. Everyone believes that everything is all about them, at some point in their lives. I know I do. How about you?
These three readings all have to do with identity.
The Evolution of Identity by the Washington Post is a timeline from the U.S. Census. It starts in 1860 and goes until the 2000 census. Over time the census has changed the way people are categorized. The only constant race category is white. There were two categories that were only listed in the 1890 census; quadroon and octoroon. A quadroon was a person with at least one-quarter black heritage and an octoroon was a person with at least one-eighth black heritage. Both of these are above the one-sixteenth, or one-drop rule amount. I wonder why it changed during only one year, 1890?
Systems keep changing, they can't help it. According to Allan G. Johnson in article #52, "No social system lasts forever." Becoming part of a solution is very challenging for people, but "We affect one another all the time without knowing it" (p. 505). On page 504, Johnson writes that Gandhi once said, "Nothing we do as individuals matters, but it's vitally important to do it anyway." This must be how we as individuals can become part of a solution to change the history of discrimination for the better. If all the people in the world would just change their nasty thoughts of who is better than whom, we would have a more peaceful existence. I can only hope.
In reading #55, by Shuddhabrata Sengupta, I learned that societies are intersectional. The author believes that identities are negotiated minefields. I think this means that throughout history there were and still are, victims and aggressors. These roles sometimes switch with each other because they are always intersecting. Everyone believes that everything is all about them, at some point in their lives. I know I do. How about you?
Thursday, July 10, 2014
Reading #s 33, 34 Disability Denial
7/10/14
Both authors, John Hockenberry and Sally French wrote about personal experiences of denial. Hockenberry was denied cab service by most drivers who would look at him in his wheelchair and then drive on by. Some would sit in their seat while Hockenberry struggled to get in, and would not take care of the wheelchair for him. He would end up getting out to look for another taxi. He even had one violent incident with a cab driver that was appalling to read about. This awful story begins on page 311, if you want to read it.
There was one taxi driver that treated Hockenberry with respect, and picked him up twice. Unfortunately he turned out to be Mahmoud Abu Holima, one of the people to plant bombs in the World Trade Center, February 26, 1993. I'm not sure of the significance of this fact, but I think it tells me that all terrorists are not discriminatory towards disabled people. Maybe even helpful. I like to believe there is positive in everyone, even among the negative.
Sally French's experience is different than John Hockenberry's. She was the one denying her disability. Not the cab drivers. She was born with limited sight, some would call legally blind. She could not see colors when young and has trouble seeing anything when the sun is too bright. Since she always heard people pleading with her, "Don't you see the rainbow?" she would just say yes to appease her family. French did not do herself a favor by this denial of her true self. It is not good to hide such things from the world. If someone has a hidden medical disability but doesn't share that fact with others it could become harmful to that person.
It is also not wise to deny one's self the pleasure of experiencing life to the fullest. I enjoy life and hope that most other people do, however they like to.
Both authors, John Hockenberry and Sally French wrote about personal experiences of denial. Hockenberry was denied cab service by most drivers who would look at him in his wheelchair and then drive on by. Some would sit in their seat while Hockenberry struggled to get in, and would not take care of the wheelchair for him. He would end up getting out to look for another taxi. He even had one violent incident with a cab driver that was appalling to read about. This awful story begins on page 311, if you want to read it.
There was one taxi driver that treated Hockenberry with respect, and picked him up twice. Unfortunately he turned out to be Mahmoud Abu Holima, one of the people to plant bombs in the World Trade Center, February 26, 1993. I'm not sure of the significance of this fact, but I think it tells me that all terrorists are not discriminatory towards disabled people. Maybe even helpful. I like to believe there is positive in everyone, even among the negative.
Sally French's experience is different than John Hockenberry's. She was the one denying her disability. Not the cab drivers. She was born with limited sight, some would call legally blind. She could not see colors when young and has trouble seeing anything when the sun is too bright. Since she always heard people pleading with her, "Don't you see the rainbow?" she would just say yes to appease her family. French did not do herself a favor by this denial of her true self. It is not good to hide such things from the world. If someone has a hidden medical disability but doesn't share that fact with others it could become harmful to that person.
It is also not wise to deny one's self the pleasure of experiencing life to the fullest. I enjoy life and hope that most other people do, however they like to.
Tuesday, July 8, 2014
Reading #s 31, 44, 45, 46
7/8/14
Inequality, how unfair!
I still don't get why people all over the world can agree or take part in racial discrimination. After reading the above four articles, I am even more disgusted in the behavior of so many of our country's citizens.
As I read about social inequality in article #31, Alejandro Reuss wrote that such inequality was related to the early death of people. Social inequality is also more prevalent with minorities. These groups generally live in poverty. The mortality rate was higher in people living in poverty because they had a lack of access to appropriate health care. Usually because of no health insurance. I am glad that our state of Vermont has good insurance for those living in poverty. Hopefully with the Affordable Care Act others with no way to get insurance will be able to now. Although some people have zero income and can't even pay for the minimum required by Federal law. That's another conversation.
On page 443, in article #44, the author discusses crossing the color line. I learned more about the one-drop rule and how it was dealt with in Virginia. In 1691 a statute was enacted that interracial marriage was illegal. If a mixed race couple was caught they would be banished for life from even entering Virginia. If a person had one-sixteenth or more of "black blood" they were considered negro. As you may be able to tell I have trouble even writing some of this.
Framing Class by Diana Kendall was about how the media constructs reality, mostly on television, but also magazines, papers, movies and more. The working class, and poor, are more likely to watch TV. They like to emulate the middle and upper classes since they cannot be in those categories. Kendall calls this, Emulation Framing. This is an ideological construction that the media frames for those in poverty. The media sees poverty as a problem of individuals, not society, (p. 451).
Lastly, article #46 is also about inequality. Cheryl I. Harris, and Devon W. Carbado, discuss how this was evident after Katrina hit New Orleans. This was clearly racial inequality between, blacks and whites. The black people were assumed to be criminals looting stores. The white people were assumed to be homeless from the hurricane, and finding food to survive. This is because mainstream America does not see racism as a problem. They are "color blind." Racial frames shape our perceptions of the facts. People are ready to accept the journalists perceptions. Again, the media is constructing how we see things.
Inequality, how unfair!
I still don't get why people all over the world can agree or take part in racial discrimination. After reading the above four articles, I am even more disgusted in the behavior of so many of our country's citizens.
As I read about social inequality in article #31, Alejandro Reuss wrote that such inequality was related to the early death of people. Social inequality is also more prevalent with minorities. These groups generally live in poverty. The mortality rate was higher in people living in poverty because they had a lack of access to appropriate health care. Usually because of no health insurance. I am glad that our state of Vermont has good insurance for those living in poverty. Hopefully with the Affordable Care Act others with no way to get insurance will be able to now. Although some people have zero income and can't even pay for the minimum required by Federal law. That's another conversation.
On page 443, in article #44, the author discusses crossing the color line. I learned more about the one-drop rule and how it was dealt with in Virginia. In 1691 a statute was enacted that interracial marriage was illegal. If a mixed race couple was caught they would be banished for life from even entering Virginia. If a person had one-sixteenth or more of "black blood" they were considered negro. As you may be able to tell I have trouble even writing some of this.
Framing Class by Diana Kendall was about how the media constructs reality, mostly on television, but also magazines, papers, movies and more. The working class, and poor, are more likely to watch TV. They like to emulate the middle and upper classes since they cannot be in those categories. Kendall calls this, Emulation Framing. This is an ideological construction that the media frames for those in poverty. The media sees poverty as a problem of individuals, not society, (p. 451).
Lastly, article #46 is also about inequality. Cheryl I. Harris, and Devon W. Carbado, discuss how this was evident after Katrina hit New Orleans. This was clearly racial inequality between, blacks and whites. The black people were assumed to be criminals looting stores. The white people were assumed to be homeless from the hurricane, and finding food to survive. This is because mainstream America does not see racism as a problem. They are "color blind." Racial frames shape our perceptions of the facts. People are ready to accept the journalists perceptions. Again, the media is constructing how we see things.
Friday, July 4, 2014
Reading #s 19, 20 The Deaf World
7/4/14
Living in the Deaf World is reality for many people. I had some brief exposure to that world in two different schools during my career. The first was with two boys who were in my first grade class, in different years. They both were profoundly deaf. The parents were not however, but extremely supportive of what the school was doing at the time. Teachers, including myself, were trained in American Sign Language and how to adapt unit plans to include as much sign as possible.
The second encounter was also at a school, with an autistic, profoundly deaf girl just beginning puberty. All that we could do for this girl was to teach her basic life skills, knowing that someday as an adult she would be living under supervision somewhere. One of her mothers was profoundly deaf, and the other was hard of hearing and used hearing aids. This family lived in the Deaf World.
I can understand how the two mothers felt in reading number 19, by Liza Mundy. Here, both moms were profoundly deaf, so they wanted their second baby to also be the same. The first child was also profoundly deaf. For this family being deaf is not a disability, but an ethnic group, as discussed by Harlan Lane in reading number 20.
Lane suggests that the Deaf World is an ethnic group because it has a name, community, behaviors, values, knowledge, kinship, customs, social structure, Language, Art, and History. He says that the aforementioned qualities signify an ethnic group. This makes sense to me. The only time I ever feel disabled by my diabetes is when my blood sugar level gets too low. Disability and ethnicity are social constructs, as are some other master statuses. You are born into a race and usually have a distinctive gender. There are some incidents when a baby is born with both physically visible genitalia. That is a different topic for another discussion.
In 2003 a law was passed to help with discrimination against minorities. This law will protect the Deaf World from discrimination for two reasons. One, the people are considered an Ethnic group. Two, they are considered a Linguistic minority. On page 181, Lane describes the United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Persons Belonging to National, or Ethnic, Religious, and Linguistic Minorities.
Living in the Deaf World is reality for many people. I had some brief exposure to that world in two different schools during my career. The first was with two boys who were in my first grade class, in different years. They both were profoundly deaf. The parents were not however, but extremely supportive of what the school was doing at the time. Teachers, including myself, were trained in American Sign Language and how to adapt unit plans to include as much sign as possible.
The second encounter was also at a school, with an autistic, profoundly deaf girl just beginning puberty. All that we could do for this girl was to teach her basic life skills, knowing that someday as an adult she would be living under supervision somewhere. One of her mothers was profoundly deaf, and the other was hard of hearing and used hearing aids. This family lived in the Deaf World.
I can understand how the two mothers felt in reading number 19, by Liza Mundy. Here, both moms were profoundly deaf, so they wanted their second baby to also be the same. The first child was also profoundly deaf. For this family being deaf is not a disability, but an ethnic group, as discussed by Harlan Lane in reading number 20.
Lane suggests that the Deaf World is an ethnic group because it has a name, community, behaviors, values, knowledge, kinship, customs, social structure, Language, Art, and History. He says that the aforementioned qualities signify an ethnic group. This makes sense to me. The only time I ever feel disabled by my diabetes is when my blood sugar level gets too low. Disability and ethnicity are social constructs, as are some other master statuses. You are born into a race and usually have a distinctive gender. There are some incidents when a baby is born with both physically visible genitalia. That is a different topic for another discussion.
In 2003 a law was passed to help with discrimination against minorities. This law will protect the Deaf World from discrimination for two reasons. One, the people are considered an Ethnic group. Two, they are considered a Linguistic minority. On page 181, Lane describes the United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Persons Belonging to National, or Ethnic, Religious, and Linguistic Minorities.
Thursday, July 3, 2014
Reading #s 6, 7
7/3/14
More articles about race. In this case they are about being white, and/or multiracial.
On p. 89, Ruth Frankenburg writes that whiteness is taken for granted sometimes, because being white has advantages and privileges that other races in America do not have as abundantly. She talks about two kinds of whiteness: truly/only white and, white plus some other race. We used to call this biracial, but in the next reading I learned about multiracial people.
In article #7 Jennifer Lee and Frank D. Bean discuss the idea that America used to be a biracial nation, mostly whites and some blacks. Now we live in a multiracial nation with multiple ethnic groups within each race. In fact, 1:40 persons in America is multiracial. To me this sounds like our country is finally becoming a little more tolerant about intermarriages. As of the 2000 census people could choose one or more races on the form.
All of this thinking about race, gives me hope that someday people all across the globe will become tolerant of each other. I grew up in the 60s and 70s: Give Peace a Chance. Okay, so we had to fight for our freedom, time and time again throughout history. However, I am glad the United States is a peaceful country at home, but what about in all the other countries we are supposedly helping?
More articles about race. In this case they are about being white, and/or multiracial.
On p. 89, Ruth Frankenburg writes that whiteness is taken for granted sometimes, because being white has advantages and privileges that other races in America do not have as abundantly. She talks about two kinds of whiteness: truly/only white and, white plus some other race. We used to call this biracial, but in the next reading I learned about multiracial people.
In article #7 Jennifer Lee and Frank D. Bean discuss the idea that America used to be a biracial nation, mostly whites and some blacks. Now we live in a multiracial nation with multiple ethnic groups within each race. In fact, 1:40 persons in America is multiracial. To me this sounds like our country is finally becoming a little more tolerant about intermarriages. As of the 2000 census people could choose one or more races on the form.
All of this thinking about race, gives me hope that someday people all across the globe will become tolerant of each other. I grew up in the 60s and 70s: Give Peace a Chance. Okay, so we had to fight for our freedom, time and time again throughout history. However, I am glad the United States is a peaceful country at home, but what about in all the other countries we are supposedly helping?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)